well played sir :) and a valid point.
I fully agree with working hard, learning everything there is to know and learning how to do it well. There is nothing worse than someone graduating from film school, buying a video capable DSLR, and running around town calling themselves a DP/Cinematographer. I was shooting some B-cam stuff in full daylight last week, and the "DP" was operating A cam, I heard a strange clicking while he was setting up his shot and when he wasn't looking I checked his settings. He was controlling exposure with shutter speed, shooting at 1/2000....I sighed and continued shooting my stuff with perfect exposure at the proper 180 degree shutter.
Again, you're points are totally valid and make sense, but I'll add that for a lot of people, making pieces of crap is how they are studying/putting in work/getting experience. There has always been tons of crap out there, but when Richard Linklater was hanging out in Austin shooting experimental films and FULLY LEARNING everything he could about using the camera, editing, composition, etc. He didn't have a vimeo account to load his crap up to and show the world. The crap now has a platform, and there inlies the problem.
This is the best thing you've said and like I said in the other message, some people are just poor collaborators. What I didn't say but am taking away from this conversation, is that yes people like Soderbergh do produce results and they are extremely talented in their own right, but they could benefit tremendously by learning to collaborate with other artists