Thank you very much, and please I posted this FOR the criticism!! I'm not sure I understand the shadows part, but I'll look at it some more and try to figure it out. I hung a blind from a mike boom and shot a light through it, I probably did it wrong. As for the flat lighting, I did see that. I lit the short by eye and set things up by looking through the viewfinder and it didn't come out as I thought it would, but it came out pretty close so I do need to work on that. I didn't use any gels or flags or things because I don't have those yet, so my only control was barndoors and distance. I'm going to make some flags and get some gels and try to position my lights better.
I did put little spots on the crystal (the candlestick, carafe and ashtray) but didn't think to use a gel, as I didn't have any, I will get some and try that. Is this what you mean by a "pepper"?
Thanks again!
Matt