Two questions in a row - new here, so don't know if this is proper or not.
Anyways, we plan on editing an HD production on Final Cut Pro and would like some insight.
On a previous production we shot with HD Cam tapes and downconverted them to DV (time code lock) and then used final cut pro to do the offline. From this we took an EDL to our online and they finished it up.
We are going to invest in a G5 for this upcoming production and are exploring how to do the editing. We'll have an HD Deck, so that problem is solved. The question is whether to figure out a way to do this with the Mac, directly off the HD tapes, or again downconvert to DV. The idea of doing off the HD means that we'll spend less time and money in the online.
At a deeper look, Final Cut Pro HD, is that really HD? It only seems compatible with DVC Pro HD. Our impression is that to edit off of HD Cam with Final Cut Pro means a 5,000 dollar PCI card and then tons of storage space, even with compression, and that the compatibility with FCP HD is less than seemless.
Any ideas as to which will be the better course of action?
Thanks,
David