Shot a student short with RED + Todd AO Anamorphic lenses.
To be clear I have not shot film + anamorphic, but have shot RED and film + spherical lenses.
My main qualm was the lenses were quite old and didn't match very well, especially past 50mm. It was a creative decision to go with them, but the set available was finicky.
In terms of the package, I was impressed by the quality recorded. We haven't been in to post and to be honest I haven't even seen much of the footage. From what I have seen I am very happy considering the price of the package.
Haven't heard of a 'soft anamorph' need.
The majority of the film was shoot in broad desert daylight and the camera responded well with the usual compliment of ND + IR cut filters.
I was happy with the response to tungsten at night in a fairly low-light scenario. I haven't seen all the footage but most of the shots shot a little under came out with great range shot at 2.0, especially considering the sweet spots of anamorphics at 4.0-5.6.
Much of the film was shot with heavy hand-held work and I have a feeling some of it may have a problem considering all the responses about the rolling shutter. Most of the footage I've seen doesn't have this problem. Fingers crossed.
Build 18 came out the night before our first day and after a quick test we opted to utilize it specifically for the in-camera de-squeeze for anamorphic. As it turned out build 18 wasn't ready and we quickly rolled back to build 16, and as DP/operator I was NOT happy about framing with the squeeze. We had one down-converted monitor desqueezed, but that was a luxury afforded the director(and rightly so). I believe these issues have been fixed but I have also heard RED ditched anamorphic support altogether(?).
I'm sure this has been discussed endlessly but you also must crop the 4K ANA image down to 2.40, so technically you are using a bit less of the quoted resolution the camera claims to record. I found this wasn't a problem as long as my compositions were as intended(but as I said irritating with the in-camera squeeze), and that I was willing to part with the thrown out portion of the frame data.
Please find a work in progress (lacks any post work) quick edit semblance of a trailer for the short here:
www.jeremymlundborg.com/Ephemera/METAL_BOX.mov
There are some tech issues involved: a hot mirror reflection, imbalanced lenses(specifically the 100mm which can been seen in what looks like underexposed pastel-ish two shots - but that is a condition of this specific set of Todd AOs), the infamous RED dot in the sun, etc.
I'll attempt to note the progress in post and my thoughts.
I'm sorry I can't be insanely technical about this, but if you have any more specific questions feel free to ask and I will do my best to answer.
Jeremy