I can only compare Zeiss super speeds and my set of Kinetals but the looks are quite different. The Kinetals are much warmer - although some of this may be due to yellowing. I have a later serial Kinetal and it's a bit cooler and brighter so if you can find later models they'd probably match closer. Still the Kinetals are a bit softer, less contrasty, and have slightly more falloff/vignette. I prefer the look. The Zeiss are more contrasty, cooler, and consistent across the frame. I have some test frames I can share if I can find them. Schneider Kreuznach Arri-S lenses might match a little closer to the Zeiss in terms of color temp but I haven't used them in some time.