Jump to content
Fran Tilley

Best compression for TV broadcast?

Recommended Posts

Hi guys, I am a recently graduated directing student and wasn't taught about the in depth technical aspects of broadcasting frame rates, NTSC and PAL. So please bear with me!

 

My film will be broadcast on TV but I need to send the file to the TV station online (its due on monday in a foreign country)- do you know a compression setting that I can use for decent broadcast-able footage yet is a good enough size to send online? I am only familiar with H.264 for youtube and vimeo.

 

It is approx 13 minutes- when I compress will have to change the 23.98 fps of NTSC to PAL at 25 fps in compressor (I did a trial and the playback was okay). It was my first time shooting and was just a trial project that was meant to be web based. That's why I didn't plan the shoot for it to be broadcast on TV and on the PAL system but it gained some interest cos of the topic and would really appreciate if anyone could help me. I have compressor..

 

Thanks!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi guys, I am a recently graduated directing student and wasn't taught about the in depth technical aspects of broadcasting frame rates, NTSC and PAL. So please bear with me!

 

My film will be broadcast on TV but I need to send the file to the TV station online (its due on monday in a foreign country)- do you know a compression setting that I can use for decent broadcast-able footage yet is a good enough size to send online? I am only familiar with H.264 for youtube and vimeo.

 

It is approx 13 minutes- when I compress will have to change the 23.98 fps of NTSC to PAL at 25 fps in compressor (I did a trial and the playback was okay). It was my first time shooting and was just a trial project that was meant to be web based. That's why I didn't plan the shoot for it to be broadcast on TV and on the PAL system but it gained some interest cos of the topic and would really appreciate if anyone could help me. I have compressor..

 

Thanks!!

How big is your original file and what format is it in?

The answer is simply that you should only compress it down to the biggest size that you can send, or they can receive. The more bits, the better the quality, simple enough. Most compression software gives you the option of setting the final file size in advance. As for the format, well, lots of commercials have been recorded as MPEG4 on a 5D...

However it also depends on the quality of your original file, above a certain data rate, it may not make any worthwhile difference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How big is your original file and what format is it in?

The answer is simply that you should only compress it down to the biggest size that you can send, or they can receive. The more bits, the better the quality, simple enough. Most compression software gives you the option of setting the final file size in advance. As for the format, well, lots of commercials have been recorded as MPEG4 on a 5D...

However it also depends on the quality of your original file, above a certain data rate, it may not make any worthwhile difference.

 

Hi Keith,

 

Thanks for the suggestions. I haven't exported it yet but I am estimating 7GB as the 10 minute trial export I did was 6GB. It will be a quicktime .mov file. Would you have any suggestions as to what bit rates I should be aiming for in order to get a 500MB file? The receiver has a slow server so that would be the best compromise...

 

Also- what aspect ratio should I look at if converting from (NTSC) HDTV 1080i (16:9) to PAL? I will be converting it to PAL first using Apple ProRes 422 (LT) before I compress the file..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the file limit for lots of free file transfer sites is 2 gig. I would compress it to that size, again for maximum quality. keep it as a ProRes LT file and send that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Keith,

 

Thanks for the suggestions. I haven't exported it yet but I am estimating 7GB as the 10 minute trial export I did was 6GB. It will be a quicktime .mov file. Would you have any suggestions as to what bit rates I should be aiming for in order to get a 500MB file? The receiver has a slow server so that would be the best compromise...

 

Also- what aspect ratio should I look at if converting from (NTSC) HDTV 1080i (16:9) to PAL? I will be converting it to PAL first using Apple ProRes 422 (LT) before I compress the file..

Well, 13 minutes x 60 seconds = 780 seconds

500MB x 8 = 4,000 megabits

4,000 divided by 780 = 5.128 megabits/sec

 

As for the aspect ratio, if you mean actual CCIR PAL with a subcarrier and so on, as used for analog broadcasts in Europe, there is only one aspect ratio 4:3.

If by "PAL" you mean 25 pictures/sec digital, the aspect ratio is exactly the same as for "NTSC" HDTV, (but you really mean ATSC HDTV).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay Chris- thanks I will aim for that using Keith's calculations for bit rate.

 

Keith- it is PAL that will be broadcast from South Africa. Again- I may be wrong but I believe it is the 25 fps version (I am still waiting for the reply from the TV station). That calculation has helped me with future knowledge and clarification on bitrates- again, much appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Fran

 

Most Broadcasters will tell you what file format and bit-rate they require. Its best just to stick to that. In the UK one of the standard delivery formats for SD is 50Mbit/s Mpeg-2. Generally they want all deliveries to be the same bit-rate/format so their are no issues with trans-coding. So even if there are more efficient codecs, mpeg-2 is still used a-lot in transmission.

 

Even if you can get similar quality with smaller files the broadcaster may specify a certain file size and you just have to stick to it. The BBC spec is very clear on whats required in the UK: http://www.bbc.co.uk/guidelines/dq/contents/television.shtml

 

Maybe your broadcaster has a similar document for SD submission's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay Chris- thanks I will aim for that using Keith's calculations for bit rate.

 

Keith- it is PAL that will be broadcast from South Africa. Again- I may be wrong but I believe it is the 25 fps version (I am still waiting for the reply from the TV station). That calculation has helped me with future knowledge and clarification on bitrates- again, much appreciated.

SA uses pretty much identical PAL to Europe, (25fps 4.43MHz subcarrier) and there aren't any digital transmissions, so your aspect ratio has to be 4:3. However I'd strongly recommend you leave your project in its original aspect ratio and let them work out how to display it.

Since it will only be displayed in PAL, 5Mb/s MPEG4 will be more than good enough for submitting it. You don't have to worry too much about format conversion, they will have all the necessary conversion software; you can even get freeware that does a perfectly adequate job. Most stations have a large collection of such software, so they have a chance that they can find at least one that can handle some of the "weirdo" cellphone video formats their Newsdesks get sent!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Fran

 

In the UK one of the standard delivery formats for SD is 50Mbit/s Mpeg-2. .

50Mbit/s Mpeg-2?

50Mbit/s is the bit rate for DV (SD digital Betacam), which is more or less Motion JPEG.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Digibetas are generally used for capture and intermediate storage in the broadcasters I've worked for, for standard definition applications. HDCAM-SR for most HD, or DNxHD, as many more people are using EVS for studio capture/insert playback.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yarp, 50Mbs Mpeg-2. In the Uk most delivery is still on tape Digi-Beta for SD and Hdcam-SR for HD. But more broadcasters are taking files, particularly for commercials and music videos etc..

 

50Mbs is good enough quality to give the video a decent chance of surviving re-compression down to 2-3Mbs for transmission. Tape deliveries are cached to server for transmission and when I worked in transmission we 50Mbs for SD.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Broadcast Solutions Inc



    FJS International



    New Pro Video - New and Used Equipment



    Just Cinema Gear



    Rig Wheels Passport



    Tai Audio



    Gamma Ray Digital Inc



    Ritter Battery



    CineLab



    Wooden Camera



    Abel Cine



    Paralinx LLC



    Media Blackout - Custom Cables and AKS



    G-Force Grips



    Visual Products



    Serious Gear



    Metropolis Post



    The Original Slider



    Glidecam


    Cinematography Books and Gear
×
×
  • Create New...